available 24/7
available 24/7
partner
A serious injury changes everything. When the insurance company you’ve been paying for years delays or denies your claim, the stress becomes overwhelming. Many policyholders wonder what happens if you sue your own insurance company, especially when they’re already facing mounting medical bills after a car accident, truck crash, motorcycle collision, or other devastating injury. The insurer you trusted to provide relief becomes another barrier to your recovery. Understanding your legal rights under Wisconsin law is crucial before you decide how to move forward. At PKSD Accident and Injury Lawyers, our personal injury lawyers help injury victims hold insurance companies accountable when they fail to honor their commitments.
Yes. Wisconsin law allows policyholders to sue their own insurance company in limited situations, most often when a personal injury claim involves benefits like uninsured or underinsured motorist coverage or medical payments.
Suing your own insurance company in Wisconsin, usually for bad faith tied to an unreasonable denial or delay, means you are seeking more than just payment of the original claim. You may pursue compensation for added financial harm, emotional strain, possible attorney fees, and, in rare cases, punitive damages if the conduct was malicious. The process can include discovery, negotiation, and, in some cases, trial, and it requires careful legal navigation.
People often raise this question because they expect cooperation from their insurance company. In reality, an insurance policy is a contract. When the company fails to follow it, state law allows the policyholder to challenge that conduct in court.
Wisconsin recognizes insurance bad faith as a distinct legal claim, separate from a simple contract dispute. This distinction becomes especially important in personal injury cases where delays or denials affect medical treatment, income stability, or recovery planning.
Courts look closely at whether the insurance company had a reasonable basis for its decision and whether it properly investigated the claim. According to state law, a policyholder must show that the insurer lacked a reasonable basis for denying benefits and either knew that or recklessly ignored information showing the claim should have been paid.
Insurance companies must follow specific claim handling standards. Under the Wisconsin Administrative Code Ins 6.11, insurers must promptly acknowledge communications, conduct timely investigations, and provide reasonable assistance to policyholders during the claims process.
This duty applies directly to personal injury claims. When an insurance company delays investigating or paying a claim while medical bills continue to accumulate, that conduct may cross the line from frustrating to unlawful.
Judges and juries focus on behavior, not just outcomes. They review whether the insurance company ignored medical records or accident reports, failed to clearly explain a denial, relied on incomplete or biased evaluations, or repeatedly requested unnecessary documentation.
These factors may answer the question of what happens if you sue your own insurance company by showing whether a bad faith claim can succeed.
Documentation supports these cases. Policy language, claim notes, recorded calls, emails, and timelines help show how the insurer handled the claim. In personal injury disputes, medical records and treatment recommendations often reveal whether delays caused real harm beyond the original accident.
A lawsuit against your insurance company may involve more than the value of the original personal injury claim. Depending on the facts, compensation may include:
Punitive damages are rare but may apply when an insurer shows intentional disregard for a policyholder’s rights. Each case depends on its specific facts, not assumptions.
CALL US 24/7
After filing the lawsuit, both sides exchange information through the discovery process. This phase often uncovers internal claim handling practices, adjuster notes, and decision-making timelines that were previously invisible.
Many cases resolve during negotiation or mediation. Discovery often brings leverage because it clarifies whether the evidence can support the insurer’s position. Settlement discussions may revisit not only the injury claim but also the added harm caused by bad faith conduct.
When settlement is not possible, the case proceeds to trial. A judge or jury then determines whether the insurer acted unreasonably and what damages are applicable. This stage answers what happens if you sue your own insurance company when earlier efforts fail.
Before filing suit, preparation is essential. Review your policy carefully, keep records of all communications, and request written explanations for any denial or delay. These steps can help protect your position and preserve important evidence.
Avoid signing releases, authorizations, or settlement agreements without understanding their impact. Some documents limit future claims or waive rights related to claims made in bad faith. Once signed, reversing those decisions is difficult.
Personal injury claims are stressful enough without questioning whether your insurer is acting fairly. Learning what happens if you sue your own insurance company often brings clarity when discussions fail to resolve. At PKSD Accident and Injury Lawyers, we guide Wisconsin policyholders through their options under state law and help determine whether legal action is appropriate for their situation. Contact us at 414-333-3333 for a free consultation.
Mr. Pitman is a member of the Nursing Home Litigation Group of the American Association for Justice, the Illinois Trial Lawyers Association, the Iowa Association for Justice and the New Mexico Trial Lawyers Association. Mr. Pitman was President of the Wisconsin Association for Justice in 2013 and is a current member of the National Academy of Elder Law Attorneys (NAELA). He lectures extensively on nursing home abuse and neglect and has authored numerous articles in the area of personal injury litigation.
This page has been written, edited, and reviewed by a team of legal writers following our comprehensive editorial guidelines. This page was approved by attorney Jeffery A. Pitman, who has more than 28 years of legal experience and handled thousands of personal injury cases while obtaining millions of dollars in verdicts and settlements in Wisconsin, Illinois, Iowa and New Mexico.
Key Takeaways Catastrophic injury usually involves permanent impairment, preventing return to prior work or normal activities. Courts and insurers use the term catastrophic injury...
Key Takeaways Case value depends on medical costs, lost wages, pain, and life disruption. Severity, recovery time, and long term effects drive differences in...
Key Takeaways There is no fixed minimum payout for whiplash in Wisconsin; compensation depends on case facts. Insurers assess records, timing, consistency, and may...
